Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 Cleats: An Honest Review

Check out the In-Depth Review Video Here

Introduction

Let’s kick things off with the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4. If you’re like me, you probably had high hopes for these cleats, especially with that hefty price tag.

You’d expect top-notch performance, comfort, and style. But let me tell you, it’s not all sunshine and rainbows here. In this review, we’ll cover everything from unboxing to comfort, fit, protection, traction, stability, and even how they look.

Trust me, you’ll want to stick around for the full breakdown because there’s more to these cleats than meets the eye. Ready? Let’s get into it.

Unboxing and First Impressions 

When I first opened the box, the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 immediately caught my eye. The design is sleek, and you can tell they’ve put effort into making these look sharp.

The build quality seems solid, especially with the synthetic leather material. However, as I held them, something felt off. The cleats looked great, but there was a stiffness in the material that didn’t sit right with me.

The overall aesthetic is nice, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that they might not be as comfortable as they look. First impressions? A mix of excitement and a bit of concern.

Comfort 

When it comes to comfort, the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 is a bit of a mixed bag. On the positive side, the foam around the heel is fantastic. It wraps around your foot, giving a snug and cushioned feel.

The thick insole adds another layer of comfort, and the stretchy knit cuff around the ankle is a nice touch, making the tongue soft and flexible.

But here’s where things go downhill. The synthetic leather they used doesn’t flex with your foot at all. Every time you take a step, you can feel this weird popping sensation at the toe.

It’s like the material isn’t meant to bend, and it digs into your foot as you move. Plus, the lower lace connection sits too low and rubs against your toes, making it even more uncomfortable. Unfortunately, these issues really take away from what could have been a comfortable experience.

Fit

The fit of the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 is pretty much true to size, but there are a few things that might catch you off guard. If you’ve worn the Alpha Menace 2, you’ll remember how the fit was just right, especially around the toe box.

The 3’s, on the other hand, had a much narrower fit, which wasn’t great for everyone. Unfortunately, the Elite 4 doesn’t improve much on that.

The heel area has plenty of room, almost too much, while the toe box feels snug—maybe a bit too snug for comfort. You can actually see the odd profile of the cleat when you look at it, with a noticeable difference between the roomy heel and the tight toe area.

This imbalance in fit might not work for everyone, especially if you have wider feet. It’s something to keep in mind before making your decision.

True to Size, But…

The Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 fits true to size, but there are a few quirks you should be aware of. If you’ve worn the Alpha Menace 2, you’ll remember that perfect fit, especially around the toe box.

The Alpha Menace 3, however, had a much narrower fit, which wasn’t ideal for everyone. Unfortunately, the Elite 4 doesn’t make significant improvements in this area.

Heel vs. Toe Box

One noticeable issue is the imbalance between the heel and toe box. The heel has plenty of room—almost too much—while the toe box feels quite snug.

You can actually see the difference in the cleat’s profile, with a roomy heel and a tight toe area. This could be uncomfortable, especially for those with wider feet, and might not work for everyone. Keep this in mind if you’re considering these cleats.

Protection

When it comes to protection, the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 has some ups and downs. The material used is more durable than previous versions, but it’s still on the thin side.

If someone steps on your toes, you’re definitely going to feel it. The synthetic leather might help with longevity, but it doesn’t add much in terms of safety.

However, the cleats do feature overlays on the sides, which offer a bit of extra stability and might help in glancing blows, preventing a direct impact. While these overlays provide some level of protection, the overall thinness of the material leaves something to be desired in terms of foot safety.

Traction

The traction on the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 is a strong point, thanks to the X-frame traction plate. This design really grips the ground, especially with those triangle studs that offer excellent stability during lateral cuts.

Whether you're on grass or even wet grass, these cleats have you covered with no issues in maintaining traction.

However, on turf, the studs can dig in a bit too much, which might make quick movements feel a bit sticky. It’s something to be aware of if you play mostly on turf, but overall, the traction performance is solid across various surfaces.

Stability

Stability is another area where the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 shines. The mid-top design provides a good amount of ankle support, giving you confidence during quick cuts and sudden stops.

The overlays help lock your foot in place, while the laces can be tightened to really secure the top of your foot. The foam around the heel also plays a big role, keeping your foot snug and supported throughout your play.

Overall, these cleats offer great stability, making them reliable for intense games.

Style and Aesthetics

Visually, the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 is a decent-looking cleat, but it doesn’t quite match the charm of its predecessor, the Elite 3. I loved the low-cut look and the mesh materials on the Elite 3, which felt like a masterpiece.

The Elite 4 is fine, but it doesn’t have that same wow factor. As for colorways, you’ve got the basics like red, white, blue, and black, along with some special editions like the Travis Kelce and Saquon Barkley versions.

Public reception has been mixed—some colorways, like the NRG, didn’t go over well, while others had a better response.

Price and Value

Now, let’s talk about the price. The Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 is one of the most expensive cleats in Nike’s lineup, with team colorways starting at $210. In Canada, they go for around $270, which is steep.

When you compare them to the Alpha Menace Pro 4, which is $90 cheaper, it’s hard to justify the extra cost. The Elite 4 doesn’t feel $90 better, especially considering the comfort and fit issues.

While they have their strengths, the high price tag makes them a tough sell unless you’re a die-hard fan of the series.

Conclusion

Overall, the Nike Alpha Menace Elite 4 has some solid features, but the high price and comfort issues make it hard to fully recommend. If you’re set on Nike, the Alpha Menace Pro 4 offers better value for the money.

If you’ve tried these cleats or have any thoughts, drop a comment below—I’d love to hear your take!